PPF vs EPF vs NPS: picking the right mix
Three tax-advantaged accounts, three different trade-offs.
PPF, EPF, and NPS get lumped together as “retirement savings”, but they don’t compete for the same decision. One is mandatory the moment you’re salaried, one is a government-declared rate anyone can open voluntarily, and one has no guaranteed return at all.
Three different guarantees
| Account | Who it’s for | Return |
|---|---|---|
| PPF | Anyone, entirely voluntary | 7.1% — declared by the government every quarter, fully guaranteed |
| EPF | Mandatory for most salaried employees | 8.25% — declared by EPFO annually, guaranteed |
| NPS | Anyone, entirely voluntary | Market-linked — no guarantee, depends on your chosen equity/debt mix |
PPF caps contributions at ₹1,50,000 a year with a 15-year lock-in and is fully tax-free at maturity. EPF contributions are tied to your basic salary (12% from you, 12% from your employer, with a slice of the employer’s share diverted into a separate pension scheme). NPS lets you choose your own equity-to-debt split, but only 60% of the final corpus is tax-free — the rest must go into a mandatory annuity that pays you a taxable pension.
₹1,00,000 held for 15 years grows to ₹2,79,796 at PPF’s guaranteed 7.1%, ₹3,28,412 at EPF’s guaranteed 8.25%, and (at an assumed 10% return — not guaranteed) ₹4,17,725 in NPS. The ranking isn’t really about which account is “best” — it’s the price of moving up the risk ladder from a government-guaranteed rate to a market-linked one.
What the same money looks like in each
For most salaried employees, EPF isn’t really a choice — it’s already happening automatically every month. The real 3-way decision is usually just “PPF vs. NPS” for whatever additional voluntary savings you want to set aside beyond EPF.
Project your Public Provident Fund maturity value across the lock-in.
Project your National Pension System corpus and expected annuity.
How to actually mix them
A reasonable starting framework: let EPF run as your automatic, mandatory base if you’re salaried — there’s no decision to make there beyond an optional voluntary top-up. Use PPF as the safe, guaranteed anchor for money you’re genuinely comfortable locking away for 15 years. Consider NPS mainly for its extra Section 80CCD(1B) deduction — ₹50,000 over and above the regular 80C cap — and only if you’re comfortable with market-linked risk and the mandatory annuity requirement at exit.
The exact numbers depend on your own contribution amount and time horizon — the EPF Calculator projects your automatic corpus, while the two calculators below let you compare the voluntary options directly.
All figures are indicative and for educational purposes only — not financial advice.
Related reading
More articles worth reading next.